Water charging encourages water efficiency, says report
Flat-fee water charges, where users pay a fee regardless of the volume used, do not encourage efficient behaviour, says a report from the European Environment Agency (EEA).
The EEA study, Assessment of cost recovery through water pricing, considers water pricing in several EU countries: Croatia, England and Wales, France, Germany, the Netherlands, Scotland, Serbia, Slovenia and Spain.
Water is under stress in many parts of Europe. Even in regions which usually experience a high level of rainfall, abstracting and cleaning water can have a high economic and environmental cost.
The EEA said this means that Europe needs to redouble efforts in using water more efficiently to avoid undermining its economy. Inefficient water use impacts hard on the resources needed by ecosystems and people.
The report stated that water should be priced at a level which both encourages efficient use and properly reflects its cost. This should include all costs of purifying and transporting the water.
In addition, environmental and resource costs of water use, such as pollution and the depletion of resources, should also be internalised into water prices. The EEA report said water charges should factor in lost 'ecosystem services' which also require water, for example wetlands carry out valuable services such as water purification and flood prevention.
The report said that in Scotland and some places in England and Wales, where water is charged in relation to the value and size of the property, not only is the water billing method more expensive for the customer, but it also reduces any incentives for increased household water-use efficiency.
The report lists some examples of water use responding to pricing. Urban water prices in Denmark increased by 54 % between 1993 and 2004 along with infrastructure investments. Over a decade water use per person per day fell by almost 20% to 125l, one of the lowest levels of any OECD country.
Water prices in the Czech Republic increased in real terms since 1990, resulting in a 40% decrease in domestic water use.
Studies reveal that charging by volume can reduce the amount of water used in agriculture by 10-20%, but in most countries, farmers are also allowed to use unlimited water for a flat charge. Switching to volumetric charging is most successful when combined with more modern irrigation technology and work to fix leaks, the report says.
The EU Water Framework Directive calls for member states to create incentives for efficient water use by 2010. However, it is unclear whether this has in fact resulted in any change in national policies, according to the EEA.
- Households use around a third less water when they are charged for the actual amount they use. However, flat-rate charging structures are still common in many countries, even though such tariffs are more expensive for most water users and do not incentivise efficient water use
- Some water uses, such as drinking water, are not significantly influenced by changes in price. However, studies show that other uses are much more responsive, including water for gardening or swimming pools
- In most countries, household water tariffs are designed to recover the financial costs. In contrast, agricultural water use is often heavily subsidised, so the price covers as little as 20 % of costs in some cases. In Spain, where some regions are severely water-stressed, agricultural water prices recover less than half of the cost. This may encourage inefficient water use, the report says.
- When the price of using water does not recover the full cost, some of the cost may be inadvertently passed on to others. For example, if industry pollutes water and fails to pay for it to be cleaned, these costs are imposed on society
- Low-income households must also have access to affordable water services, but keeping prices artificially low for all users is not the best method, the report says, as it may lead to a vicious cycle of underfunded service providers with poor infrastructure
- The public seems to support being charged according to the volume of water they use – 84 % of EU citizens agree with this principle to some extent, according to a 2012 Eurobarometer survey.
- A transition to metering is still on-going in England and Wales. In 2009 the Walker Review reported that only about 28% of households were metered. The report says that if these recommendations are fully implemented, it is estimated that about 80% of households in England and Wales will be metered by 2020
Hans Bruyninckx, EEA executive director, said: “In many parts of Europe, profligate water use is a real problem. However, there is a lot of potential for Europe to cut water use by improving efficiency. Charging water users for the volume of water they actually use, at a price reflecting the true cost, sends an important signal – freshwater is a limited and precious resource.”
- Anglian Water to hold ‘shop window' event for innovators Anglian Water is challenging innovators to create the water company of the future by showcasing their pioneering... Read More >
- Scottish Water delivers highest levels of customer satisfaction Scottish Water delivered its highest-ever levels of customer satisfaction and invested £627M in new water and wastewater... Read More >
- SEPA commended for innovative technology use on river restoration The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) has won an award for using innovative technology to carry out... Read More >
- Integrated catchment management James Knightbridge of Mott MacDonald examines what systems operation means in terms of integrated catchment management and... Read More >
- Rewarding excellence WWT content director Alec Peachey looks ahead to next year's Water Industry Awards. Read More >
- Achieving zero interruptions and leakage Rik Gunderson, UK utility director at Software AG, looks ahead to WWT's Water Industry Innovation Conference. Read More >
- Getting personal Save Water Save Money's aqKWa Savings Engine is helping people around the world to understand precisely how they can... Read More >
- Changing the way water utilities think George Hesmondhalgh, managing consultant at Capgemini, says companies need to stop viewing legislation as an obligation... Read More >