Researchers back ‘natural' flood engineering
Back-to-nature flood schemes could be a cost-effective way of tackling flooding of low- lying land, say researchers at Newcastle University. Using Belford Burn in Northumberland as a demonstration pilot, the team have shown that by changing and hindering the natural flow pathways within a small catchment system, it is possible to manage the amount of run-off from the land.
The schemes include capturing flow upstream to prevent floods downstream, where they are likely to have a greater impact on infrastructure and homes. The work, which also cuts down on pollution by preventing phosphorous and nitrates from being washed off the land, have been trialled as part of a five-year research project in partnership with the Environment Agency.
Published this month’s in Science of the Total Environment journal, the findings were presented at the House of Commons Office of Science & Technology last week, and are expected to inform the government’s environment white paper.
Research lead, Mark Wilkinson, who carried out the work while at Newcastle University and is now based at the James Hutton Institute in Aberdeen, said: “Climate projections for the UK suggest that total rainfall during winter months will continue to rise and with it the risk of flooding. What we have shown at Belford is that by employing so-called ‘soft engineering solutions’ to restrict the progress of water through a catchment – disconnecting fast-flow pathways and adding storage – we have been able to reduce the risk of flooding in the lower areas and, most importantly, in the town.
“Belford is not unique and there are many other areas around the UK where these solutions could make a significant impact and potentially protect peoples’ homes from some of the more severe flooding we are seeing at the moment.”
Natural Flood Management (NFM) aims to reduce the downstream maximum water height of a flood – the peak – or delay the arrival of the flood peak downstream, increasing the time available to prepare.
This is done by restricting the progress of water through a catchment and relies on one, or a combination of four key mechanisms which work with the environment to provide a sustainable solution to the problem:
- Storing water such as ponds, ditches and field attenuation bunds
- Increasing soil infiltration through the creation of ‘infiltration zones’ to help water get into the soil at certain locations, for example tree belts.
- Slowing water by increasing resistance to its flow, for example planting in the floodplain or riverside woodland
- Redirecting the water by channelling it away from the main flow into temporary water storage areas or buffer zones to hold the water back until the flood peak drops or restoring river meanders. This increases the length of the river and decreases its slope, slowing down the flow
Costing around £200,000, the Belford scheme was installed after a study of the area suggested the cost of a full conventional flood defence scheme for the town would cost in the region of £2.5M.
“The situation in Belford is typical of many rural towns around the UK that are at risk of flooding,” explained Dr Paul Quinn, based in the School of Civil Engineering & Geosciences at Newcastle University. “It is a town with a long history of flooding, but the floods tend to be short-lived – albeit severe – and only tend to affect a small number of properties.
A feasibility study concluded that traditional flood defences were not suitable because of the high-cost, lack of space for flood walls and banks and the relatively small number of properties involved.”
Just five months after the feasibility report was published, the July 2007 storm hit the North of England and ten homes and businesses in Belford were flooded. It was after this event the Newcastle University demonstrator project was launched.
“One of the main reasons why the Belford scheme has been such a success is because we’ve had the support of the community and local landowners behind us,” explained Quinn, who has since carried out a second catchment management scheme at Netherton Burn, Northumberland. “There is no single solution to flooding – no ‘silver bullet’ – but what the Belford scheme has shown us is what can be achieved with local support and a
Belford Burn is one of series of full-scale demonstrator projects being developed by Newcastle University. Similar schemes have started at Netherton, Upper Wansbeck, Great Ayton, Powburn, the Ouseburn and Hepscott working in partnership with the Environment Agency.
Other projects include Science Central in Newcastle city centre, which will become a test bed for urban sustainability. Research projects include novel planting designs to create carbon-capture gardens and a £2M grid-scale energy storage test bed that will pave the way for the future of smart grids and energy storage across the UK.
- Scotland's bathing water pass European standards All of Scotland's 83 beaches have passed European water quality standards, the Scottish Environment Protection Agency... Read More >
- Government aims to eliminate wet wipes within 25 years The Department of Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) has confirmed it aims to eliminate wet wipes as part of its... Read More >
- Amey and VTOL form drone JV for asset management inspections Asset management consultancy Amey and drone technology expert VTOL Technologies have formed a joint venture - AmeyVTOL -... Read More >
- Tyre microplastics pollution: Ignore it or remove it? Tyre microplastics is one of the largest sources of pervasive pollution in the water environment, yet consistently ignored... Read More >
- Meeting the SuDS challenge A report indicates that the UK has a long way to go on implementing sustainable drainage systems, yet advice and... Read More >
- Capital's infrastructure needs integrated water approach The concerns of Londoners about the capital city's resilience highlight the need for integrated planning across water,... Read More >
- Ready for anything: Resilience in the Round Resilience is one of the four priorities that Ofwat wants to see water companies adopt in their plans for PR19. But what... Read More >
- Moving towards greener resilience Nature-based solutions can help us to see the big picture when building in system resilience, writes Dr Jonathan Simm,... Read More >