Service reservoir project refreshes supply in Burton-on-Trent
Stonbury's project to construct a new service reservoir for South Staffs Water achieved the best whole-life asset solution while overcoming challenges relating to ecology and weather
When Stonbury were tasked with the replacement of a service reservoir for South Staffs Water, the project team were able to deliver an impressive whole-life asset solution while engaging with the community effectively and ensuring continuity of supply.
Outwoods Reservoir was originally constructed in 1882 in Burton upon Trent. Following an increase in demand, Outwoods Reservoir No.2 was added in 1962. In 2016 Reservoir No.1 was finally taken out of service after proving increasingly expensive to update and maintain. In 2017 South Staffs Water awarded Stonbury the contract to replace Outwoods Reservoir No.1.
The Outwoods supply zone, fed from a number of storage reservoirs at Outwoods in Burton Upon Trent, includes approximately 26,000 properties in Burton upon Trent, Rolleston on Dove, Barton under Needwood, Alrewas, Fradley, and Streethay, with a combined total average daily demand of 23 million litres.
The project was challenging with a tight programme and proximity of protected species, but achieving the deadline has ensured the supply network can continue to operate and provide a safe and reliable water supply for current and future generations.
South Staffs had originally been awarded planning permission for a new reservoir on the footprint of Reservoir No. 1 in 2014. The project was delayed due to unexpected work on other schemes within the South Staffs Water supply network. Whilst the site was still able to function it was important that both storage capacity and resilience of the site were increased.
The decision was made to locate the new reservoir on a greenfield area of the site rather than in the footprint of Reservoir 1 to reduce the overall construction programme and meet supply demand. This would not only enable South Staffs to operate two reservoirs at all times, but also opened up the opportunity to build an additional reservoir in the future on the footprint of Reservoir No1. This investment will help to guarantee the quality and reliability of the local water supply for the next 100 years, and play a key part in meeting growing demand from new housing being built in the area.
Stonbury has worked closely with South Staffs Water for many years, currently holding a five-year Framework for Reservoir Refurbishment. Although nationally the company typically refurbishes around 450 reservoirs annually, this is the first time Stonbury have been responsible for a new build reservoir.
The tender process involved a high level of optioneering of all possible solutions, including temporary tanks, steel tanks and GRP tanks. The option selected was a hybrid solution for a reinforced concrete structure, which included precast concrete columns and roof structure. This was deemed to be the most cost-effective solution in respect of both whole life costs and design life, as well as one capable of being delivered to the very challenging programme.
Stonbury subsequently completed the detailed design stage, which developed the outline design, submitted at tender stage. It was decided to split the reservoir into two 5Ml tanks to speed construction and enable delivery of one of those tanks into service at the earliest opportunity and further increasing long term storage resilience.
From the date that Stonbury gained access to the site on the 9 March 2017, there was a 16-week timeline specified by South Staffs before commissioning the first reservoir by 1 July 2017.
Shortly before work was due to begin, an ecology evaluation highlighted the presence of Great Crested Newts on a housing development adjacent to the site. As a European protected species, these animals, their eggs, breeding sites and resting places are safeguarded by law.
Following a full ecological survey an environmental specialist and licensed ecologists were brought to site to work alongside Stonbury to prepare the site for construction in the shortest possible timescale.
Whilst no GCN or nests were physically found on site the erection of reptile barrier fencing and hibernaculum ensured the protection of GCN during and beyond construction.
Coping with the delay
The steps taken to protect the Great Crested Newts did, however, have a severe knock-on effect on the work schedule. A full eight days were lost on the commencement of excavation work.
An additional element was also added to the original specification: the construction of a concrete valve chamber to house all the pipework coming into and out of the reservoir. This was to be a 12.8m long by 6.8m wide by 4.85m high structure.
These delays, as well as heavy rain severely affecting progress on several days, presented Stonbury with the main challenge of the project. South Staffs Water agreed to adjust the budget to allow for 12-hour day and weekend working by the team, with some personnel then on duty every weekend. The team of people assigned included up to 25 operatives at any one point.
Whilst the team were able to work the additional hours to bring the project in on time, accelerating the schedule meant that problems arose with the timely delivery of key materials.
The original date set for commissioning the reservoir on 1 July 2017 was met, and the first stage was to fill it for its seven-day testing.
The final inspection was conducted by the client and the project deemed completed and handed over. The reservoir was then dropped, re-cleaned, filled and sampled for return to service the week commencing 10 July, just 17 weeks from breaking ground.
Ahead of work beginning on site, Stonbury and South Staffs embarked on a community engagement programme with local residents. The reservoir is close to housing, and concerns had been expressed during the planning process that lorries entering and leaving the site would have a negative impact on local roads which serve a primary school and children’s nursery, and which regularly experience congestion at peak times.
South Staffs Water pro-actively engaged with the local residents and the nearby primary school leading up to construction to ensure everyone was informed and given the opportunity to raise concerns. The project delivery team also set up a community portal system, enabling members of the public to follow progress of the scheme and to communicate directly with the delivery team, express concerns and ask questions.
Keeping local communities informed through a community portal has proved beneficial; especially larger schemes close to housing. As well as providing a level of transparency that can defuse potentially contentious situations, it gave Stonbury the chance to keep local people informed of changes to schedules, and to take on board constructive suggestions informed by local knowledge that will help us do a better job.
Feedback on the portal led directly to changes being made during the works programme. Early in the project, for instance, concerns were expressed about the number of lorries making deliveries to the site at peak times. As a direct consequence, the timings were changed to spread lorry journeys through the day.
Stonbury were also able to reassure local residents that the final appearance of the reservoir would enhance rather than detract from the appearance of the site. Half of the reservoir is buried, so no views have been detrimentally affected and Stonbury committed to creating a natural looking, grass-covered mound using all of the top soil excavated.
Projects like this always present challenges but the combination of unavoidable delays and tight deadlines always create extra problems.
Many of the UK’s service reservoirs are now coming up to their ‘sell-by’ date, and while refurbishment will always be the preferred option where technically feasible, replacement will often offer an economical, long-term solution for clients looking to protect their assets and ensure continuity of supply into the future.
-This feature appeared in the February 2018 issue of WET News.
- Interview: Avtar Jirh, managing director, Doosan Enpure Doosan Enpure is no ordinary process engineering company. It is a process engineering company whose in-house capabilities... Read More >
- Trant Engineering: Forward thinking Now positioned as a multi-discipline, innovation-focused contractor, Trant Engineering is aiming high - and says its... Read More >
- Project Focus: A challenging pipeline assessment at Ladybower When a vital pipeline survey was required at the 70-year-old Severn Trent dam, pipes beneath two draw-off towers presented... Read More >
- New dimensions: How BIM drove Scottish Water's Tullich WTW project With ESD making extensive use of BIM including 4D visualisation tools, Scottish Water has successfully completed a £29... Read More >
- Digital digging: OS and NWG's underground mapping system Ordnance Survey helped pioneer an idea for a new digital mapping system for underground utilities at Northumbrian Water's... Read More >
- Thames' eight2O alliance sees benefits in Active Risk Manager Alliance has deployed ARM to manage projects as part of Thames Water's capital investment programme Read More >
- Interview: New Clancy Docwra CEO Matt Cannon Former rugby union professional Matt Cannon wants to ensure water companies recognise the full value Clancy Docwra can... Read More >
- Delivering innovation for PR19 Innovation will be the key to meeting many water sector goals after PR19, and many potential technological solutions are... Read More >