Project Focus: All change for vital Severn Tunnel pumping system
An upgrade which saw two screw pumps replaced by four rotary lobe pumps has helped protect a crucial National Grid power cable under the River Severn
David Brown, Managing Director, Borger UK: “This is one of the most demanding installations we’ve ever undertaken. Reliability and back-up is absolutely crucial to this site. The Maintenance-In-Place feature provides particular benefits here, where space is at such a premium”.
Steve Parker, Substation Engineer, National Grid: “Although this upgrade has involved a capital cost, we’re already well on our way to getting that back by the huge amount of time and labour we save on servicing”.
As the first Severn Bridge approaches its 50th anniversary, the millions of drivers that cross it each year will be blissfully unaware of just how crucial the pumping operation is some 70m below the land in the tunnel that connects a vital National Grid cable from England to Wales.
Valued at £80M, the 2.2 mile tunnel is protected by pumps that remove one million litres per day of water ingress from underground springs. Systems are firmly in place to prevent homes and industry from any power shortages, but the knock-on effect from a total pump failure would cost around £1M to £1.25M per day.
Mention the Severn Bridge to most people and they’ll usually refer to the mighty construction that hosts part of the M4, but just to be clear, we’re talking here about its perhaps less glamorous neighbour, hailed as the dawn of a new economic era for South Wales when opened 30 years earlier by the Queen. This is the first Severn Bridge, slightly further up the river, which now carries part of the M48 motorway. Deep down in the tunnel with the National Grid cable, it’s a strangely warm, damp, noisy environment where the lights have to stay on and corrosion sets to work amid the somewhat eerie stalactites.
Following a refurbishment of the tunnel a decade ago when the pumping out of the spring water was reduced from two points to just one - at Aust on the English side of the Severn - National Grid has been busy working towards the best possible solution for automated control of the tunnel’s pumping system. This recently culminated in an upgrade which saw two screw pumps replaced by four rotary lobe pumps, and a major improvement in the way the system is maintained, as Substation Engineer, Steve Parker, explains.
“We’ve gone from what could be described as ‘panic breakdown maintenance’ – to a controlled, managed quarterly program”, says Parker.
“This has come on the back of switching from two screw pumps to four rotary lobe pumps made by Börger. Although this upgrade has involved a capital cost, we’re already well on our way to getting that back by the huge amount of time and labour we save on servicing.
“For the screw pumps, we’d need a minimum of three personnel just to go down into the tunnel to carry out an inspection that could take at least two and half hours. To bring one of the pumps out for repair or maintenance required winches, which then became an extremely time-consuming health and safety event, lasting up to two and half days.
“Including the cost of two full-time fitters, we’d have to jack the screw pump apart in order to cut the main rotor in half, which overall, was a costly and sacrificial exercise that I considered no longer manageable. Removal of one of the two screw pumps also left us vulnerable with a single point of failure. We needed a much smaller, more reliable, more cost-effective and easier to maintain pump regime, which is where Börger came in”.
The installation of four stainless steel Börger pumps, which was carried out by Almax Technologies, has reduced inspection time to just 40 minutes. For servicing, the Maintenance-In-Place (MIP) feature of the factory-tested pumps means that all four can be stripped down, oil changed, rotors checked, in a day (or less), right back to the gearbox seals. Fitted with “Optimum rotors”, the 18.5kW Börger units pump out 40m3 per hour at 70m head (7.5 BAR vertical discharge), and have a suction lift of -5.5m. Only two pumps are in action at any one time, operating alternately on a 20 minute shift system so as to preserve their lifetime. In the event of a flood, then all four pumps would automatically leap into action – and compared to leaving just one screw pump in place, removal of a Börger unit would still leave three working if needed. Soft-start inverters get the variable-drive pumps up and running so as not to shock the pipework.
“In fact, it’s been the existing pipework that has presented us with more problems”, continued Steve Parker. “We’re now changing over from plastic to stainless steel to reduce vibration”.
Installation of the pumps took over a month, and the system underwent intensive Witnessed Performance Testing prior to acceptance.
National Grid is also introducing a new control and monitoring system, which Parker says he held back on until the performance and maintenance of the pumps could be firmly established. Flow meters currently check on the pumps’ typical 63m3 per hour of water, but the new smart system will help improve efficiency on site even further, because a complete history will be available at an operator’s fingertips, with graphics to study trends and much more – accessible via a smart phone if required.
Parker concluded: “Compared to the saga of servicing our screw pumps, all we need to get at the Börger pumps are basic tools, which can be taken down into the tunnel with ease in a small holdall. The simplicity of the Maintenance-In-Place feature is a real benefit - four Eye-bolts on the front of each pump – and the pumps themselves are rock solid, despite being in such a harsh, almost oil-rig type environment.
They have taken massive hammerings – but been totally resilient and beautifully reliable.”
- Case study: A customised pump solution for Hinkley Point A bespoke pumping system is proving key to the water management strategy for the major nuclear project in Somerset Read More >
- Selwood provides green solution to overpumping job When overpumping was required during an upgrade of a Wessex Water pumping station in Somerset, the rental of an... Read More >
- Comment: Capital Maintenance comes to the fore The tight cost of capital set by Ofwat for PR19 will mean water companies will need to place the emphasis on maintenance... Read More >
- Flood resilience: what you need to know Geoff Williams, northern sales manager at Sykes Pumps, discusses the need for businesses and local authorities to think... Read More >
- Reaching net carbon zero In summer 2019, the water industry committed to reach net carbon zero by 2030. This is a very ambitious aim and... Read More >
- Rewarding excellence WWT content director Alec Peachey looks ahead to next year's Water Industry Awards. Read More >
- Going green at Severn Trent's Minworth STW With a £60 million investment aimed at producing 30 per cent more green energy from its largest sewage treatment works,... Read More >
- Case Study: Pumping up quality at Burnham Jetty A year's worth of planning, seamless collaboration and technical expertise were crucial to the success of a complex... Read More >