Throughlet size has no impact on clog resistance
It appears that the issue of throughlet size has again come to prominence, as pump users search for solutions to the problem of pump clogging in wastewater applications.
The most important facet of a pumping system is its ability to pump wastewater without clogging. In recent times there has been an increasing number of queries from pump users questioning throughlet size as a method of ensuring clog-free pumping in wastewater applications.
In spite of this heightened level of enquiry, throughlet size is, in reality, not an accurate measurement for the clog-free operation, particularly in today’s modern wastewater systems.
Many in the industry believe that the myth of throughlet size had been put to bed years ago, but there is still some outdated and non-factual information in the marketplace.
Throughlet size is determined by the largest diameter of a solid object that can pass through the smallest section of the pump, the passage through the impeller. There have traditionally been several types of impeller-design options available for wastewater pumping, from these the single-vane impellers and the vortex impeller designs have historically been favoured on raw sewage applications. Both of these designs have some negative qualities.
Single-vane impellers can have difficulty with balancing causing significant rotating radial forces which cause high shaft and bearing loads. This can result in increased noise and vibrations levels with relatively low levels of efficiency especially with larger throughlets. Vortex impellers, also known as recessed or torque-flow impellers, are known to be very inefficient.
The logic behind throughlet size being integral to a pumping system’s efficiency dates back to around 1915 when pump manufacturers believed that clogging could simply be avoided by having a throughlet large enough for most normal sized objects to pass through.
Decades of research has proven that this simplistic logic is false, confirming that the myth of throughlet size being the key criteria for clog-free pumping is flawed. In spite of this, it is still prevalent in wastewater pump procurement specifications.
Modern wastewater rarely contains hard spherical objects that are as large as the inner diameter of the piping system, such as stray pieces of brick or metal. What’s more, if such materials were to appear within a pumping system, it would be unlikely for them to reach the pump itself as they should become trapped on a flat horizontal surface where the liquid is stagnant or the carrying velocity is low.
In reality, modern systems are actually far more susceptible to problems caused by the presence of raggy material, such as synthetic cloth from tissues, wipes and dishcloths used in household cleaning.
Whilst homeowners should dispose of such materials in a proper manner, many continue to flush them down the toilet. As a result, there is often a continuous stream of raggy material entering the sewage system which then gets caught on the leading edge of the pump’s impeller vane, irrespective of the throughlet size. This build-up of raggy material can significantly decrease the flow rate of the pump or, if an excessive amount of raggy material is accumulated, cause the pump to completely stop altogether due to the motor being overloaded. Such occurrences will significantly affect the overall pumping system efficiency and if left untreated, will result in increased energy bills for the end-user as the pump is required to work much harder in an attempt to complete the same operation.
The ability of a pump’s impeller to effectively negotiate the build-up of long fibrous materials is arguably much more important to pump station efficiency than a pumping system’s throughlet size.
The success of advanced wastewater pumps that utilise a hydraulic self-cleaning design confirms that throughlet size is irrelevant to the efficiency of a modern day wastewater pumping station.
Whilst some claim that hydraulic designs which use vortex impellers are self-cleaning, it is not strictly accurate. Without a specific self-cleaning design the raggy material can reappear and continue to block the impeller vanes even if back flushing the pump has initially cleared the impeller. Hydraulic self-cleaning pumps are far more effective at negotiating the build-up of raggy material and solids that land on the impeller as they incorporate backswept leading edges in a radial (as opposed to axial) orientation.
These materials are instead pushed towards the periphery and out of the pump through designed relief mechanisms and unique impeller geometry. The biggest threat to efficiency for modern pumping systems is the build-up of raggy material on the impeller, not throughlet size. The installation of pumps with hydraulic self-cleaning mechanisms can reduce both the number of blockages and noticeably improve the overall efficiency of a pumping system. As such, throughlet size should not qualify as a measure for pump users and suppliers when appraising inefficient pumping stations.
- Overpumping solution helps Anglian sludge management When routine maintenance was required on business-critical sludge assets at Anglian Water's Caister WRC, a temporary... Read More >
- When rag becomes a drag... Ragging of pumps following storm flows was a big problem for South Dublin County Council, until some new pumps were... Read More >
- Protecting Your Pumps With pumps being among a water company's most critical assets, screens and automated trashrakes have a vital role to play... Read More >
- Offsite build for Affinity pumping station Taking a pioneering new approach to a borehole pumping station upgrade in Essex, Affinity Water minimised asset downtime... Read More >
- Anglian Water ends long search to improve pump station efficiency After nearly six years, Anglian Water has finally found a solution to improve efficiency at one of the largest raw water... Read More >
- Hidrostal solves problematic pump issue in residential development When a network pumping station in the Anglian Water region was suffering from repeated blockages, a more effective... Read More >
- What will the pump of the future look like? How will the pump play its part in the digital future represented by industry 4.0? Bryan Orchard explores how one... Read More >
- Component pricing: a disposable dilemma When working out the whole-life cost of a pump or similar equipment, one variable is how often components need to be... Read More >