Totex incentives a must
Industry jargon always sends a shiver down my spine and this summer it will be the words 'Totex', 'Capex' and 'Opex' getting a full airing, as Ofwat consults widely on its plans to reform the way it sets prices and regulates the expenditure of the UK water companies.
Notwithstanding the ugliness of the terminology, Ofwat's intentions set out in its Future Price Limits consultation, and embodied in the recently-published Statement of Principles, are a thing of beauty to those of us in the industry supply chain. They signal real hope that we can contribute to greater engineering innovation and develop solutions that are based on achieving the best through-life costs for our customers. Now that has to be good news for sustainability, as well as for consumers.
Ofwat has signalled its determination to tackle what it calls the 'unintended bias' of the current regulatory system towards capital expenditure amongst the water companies. As part of its far-reaching reforms for PR14, it wants to combine the assessment and incentivisation of Opex (operating costs) and Capex (capital expenditure) into a more holistic Totex (total expenditure) approach.
At the same time, Ofwat wants to move towards a system which rewards the best outcomes, rather than the outputs that can be achieved if companies play the regulatory game well.
Whilst widely welcomed by the supply chain, the Totex proposals received a lukewarm reception from water companies themselves and Ofwat has indicated it will conduct consultations, workshops and working groups over the summer before launching a Methodology Consultation in the autumn.
Working out robust mechanisms is essential, but once they are in place the same thinking will need to be applied to the way water companies let contracts to their suppliers.
Speaking from the supply chain perspective, I think this looks like another major challenge: it will mean water companies potentially letting contracts on the basis of cheaper operating and through-life costs, even when initial set-up costs appear uncompetitive.
It will simply go against the grain to let a contract to the supplier that is not the cheapest. Water companies will need to be open-minded and creative in developing the necessary scrutiny and assessment criteria for bids, as well as providing robust incentives for suppliers to deliver operating efficiencies long after they have left site.
I don't believe these challenges are insurmountable, but as debates continue this summer over the regulatory framework itself, they should not be overlooked. We should begin to get the best contracting minds to work developing ideas for the exciting future ahead.
- Over 100 Irish drinking water sources need remedial work, says regulator Over 100 drinking water supplies in Ireland still need remedial work in order to make them safe and remove the need for... Read More >
- Cobalt Water granted water supply and sewerage licence Cobalt Water has been granted a water supply and sewerage licence which would allow it to operate in the non-household... Read More >
- Amey launches 'reverse mentoring' scheme A new ‘reverse mentoring' programme that flips traditional mentoring on its head has been launched by engineering and... Read More >
- Better to be safe than sorry? 3/25/2013 11:01:52 AM "If it ain't broke - don't fix it:"So the truism goes. Why spend time and money monitoring and maintaining equipment or...
- Heavy Rainfall and Water Quality 1/3/2013 3:26:53 PM As we count the costs of last year's floods misery and find the best candidates for an extra £120m in flood defences,...
- Tackling Boom and Bust - We've only Just Begun 10/23/2012 3:02:20 PM Infrastructure UK's widely-welcomed report 'Smoothing Investment Cycles in the Water Sector' has emphatically confirmed that...
- Drought and Deluge - two sides of the same coin 9/11/2012 12:35:51 PM After the summer we've had, there's no denying how short our collective memories are when it comes to the weather. The...
- Sludge dirty secret or black gold? 5/6/2012 2:05:00 PM Culturally, the notion of sewage sludge has connotations of a dirty secret, rather than a valuable commodity. Even the name...